Sunday 10 November 2013

HRF Intervention on Itishree Pradhan Murder Case


Itishree Pradhan
Itishree Pradhan murder case, which added another chapter to the shameful history of crimes against women in Odisha. On 1st November 2013 a justice seeker 27-year-old contractual teacher (sikshya sahayak) Ms Itishree Pradhan died after she was set ablaze by dousing kerosene in her body on 27th October 2013 night by unidentified assailant(s) while she was asleep in her school hostel.

The slain lady teacher belongs to Munida village of Puri district was in job of sikshya sahayak( contractual govt. teacher) at Tikiri Upper Primary School in a tribal dominated Rayagada district ( 600 km away from her village) since 18th June 2011.
Burning Itishree in Hospital
A fact finding team of Human Rights Front(HRF) visited the place of Tikiri, Rayagada district  on where the incident happened then to Munida village of Puri district, the victim’s native village. The fact we found during the fact finding as follows...
1-      From 18.06.2011, Ms Itishree Pradhan was doing the job of Sikshya Sahayak (contractual govt. teacher) at Tikiri Upper Primary School in Rayagada District.
2-      The prime accused Mr. Netrananda Dandasena was Headmaster In-Charge when Itishree joined the school, since then he had been trying to sexually molestrate through various means and ways.
3-      On 24.11.2012 she requested through an application to district education officer for staying in school hostel premises as it was intolerable for her to stay outside or to save from the continuous harassment.
4-     On 18.07,2013 , she had logged a FIR against Mr Dandasena in Tikiri PS which is only 500mtrs away from the school
Manoj Jena with Itishree's Father
5-      On 31.07.2013 she approached to DGP for action against the culprit
Itishree house in her native Village
6-     On 19.09.2013, She again logged an FIR against the family members of Mr Dandasena as they threatened her to kill when she refused to withdraw the FIR.
7-      On 30.07.2013 she requested through separate petition to both State Women Commission(SWC) and Odisha Human Rights Commission(OHRC) for intervention, the SWC has not initiated any action but OHRC simply forwarded the petition to SP, Rayagada for appropriate action and disposed the case.
8-     0n 5.08.2013 she approached to SP of Rayagada for providing protection and action against the perpetrators, the copy of letter also sent to CM of Odisha.
9-     The victim had also met the District Magistrate twice on 28th July and 5th August 2013 and requested his action. The DM forwarded the application to sexual harassment committee.
10-   The sexual harassment committee did fact find the case on 24th August and submitted their report to DM on 27th September 2013 ,delayed more than one month. The DM saw the report only on 13th October.
11-    Due to negligence of DM, the prime accused Dandasena promoted to School Inspector
12-    On 16.08.2013 again she logged FIR against family members of the accused for taking immediate action.
13-    On 18.08.2013 she made a press release to all media with an allegation that all the grievance redressal offices have failed to provide justice.
14-   The father and elder sister of victim’s alleged that the local MP threatened her mobile phone either to withdraw the case or face any consequences.
15-    The MP and local leaders are patronising the accused Dandasena for his every misdeed.
16-   Mr Dandasena is a habitual offender as the deceased teacher mentioned in her petition.

       The whole of our fact finding reveals the fact that …
i)      All the grievance redressal offices have failed to act promptly to deliver justice to the victim.
ii)    Administrative Accountability has lapsed in this case.
iii)  Sexual Harassment committee’s callousness has observed
iv)   Ruling party political leader had patronized to the perpetrators for their petty political purposes.
v)     The police has failed to protect the life of the slain lady teacher

Follow-Up Action:
HRF filed a petition in National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) on 31st October 2013 later fact finding reports submitted to the hon’ble commission on 7th November 2013. The commission took it cognizance and gave following interim order.

          NATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION                     
          MANAV ADHIKAR BHAWAN, BLOCK-C,            
          G.P.O. COMPLEX, INA, NEW DELHI- 110023
Team HRF presenting FF report to NHRC
To,
                                                           
 THE CHIEF SECRETARY                                                                                          
GOVT. OF ODISHA, BHUBANESWAR 

Sub : Complaint from

MANOJ JENA
CHAIRPERSON,HUMAN RIGHTS FRONT(HRF)
298, GANGA NAGAR,BHUBANESHWAR
KHURDA ODISHA.

Sir/Madam,
     I am directed to say that the matter was considered by the Commission on 08/11/2013 and
the Commission has directed as follows.

The Commission received a email complaint dated 31.10.2013 from Shri Manoj Jena, an office bearer of NGO 'Human Rights Front' alleging that a woman teacher, named in the complaint, was being sexually harassed by her senior in Rayagada district of Odisha but no action was taken despite several
complaints to the authorities. Subsequently, she was threatened to withdraw the case against the accused official, and when she refused to do so, she was assaulted and set ablaze with kerosene. Now she was struggling for her life in a hospital.

The Commission took cognizance in the matter on 06.11.2013 and issued notice to the Director General of Police, Odisha, Bhubneshwar and Secretary, Department of School Education, Government of Odisha,Bhubneshwar calling for a report in the matter within six weeks.
   
However, it has been brought to the notice of the Commission that the NGO has handed over its fact
finding report dated 07.11.2013 to the Joint Registrar (Law) of the Commission during his official visit to Odisha, which states that the victim, a contractual teacher, Ms. Itishree Pradhan, 27 years, was sexually harassed by Headmaster of the School, Netrananda Dandasena, since her joining on 18.06.2011in the School. Due to this, the victim lodged an FIR on 18.07.2013 in Tikiri Police Station on 18.07.2013 against Netrananda Dandasena. As no action was taken by the police, she approached the Director General of Police on 31.07.2013. Again on 19.09.2013 she registered an FIR against the family members of Mr. Netrananda Dandasena as they had threatened to kill her if she would not
withdraw her complaint. On 05.08.2013, she approached the Superintendent of Police, Rayagada for
protection and action against the accused persons. A copy of the letter was also addressed to the 
Chief Minister, Odisha. She further registered an FIR on 16.08.2013 against the accused persons and
requested immediate action. As no action was taken, on 18.08.2013 the victim informed the media that nobody was addressing her grievances. Subsequently, she was set ablaze by the accused persons and died on 27.10.2013. Her father and elder sister have alleged that the accused were being shield by the local Member of Parliament.

The Joint Registrar (Law) also obtained copies of order dated 05.11.2013 issued by Government of
Odisha, vide which Shri Sujit Kumar Say, IIC Police Station, Tikiri and Shri Muralidhara Pradhan, ASI,Tikiri have been dismissed from their services under Article 311 (2) (b) of the Constitution of India.
The Commission has considered the material placed on record and notices that the victim lady had
approached all the possible channels but no effort was made by the State authorities to address her
grievances and to save her life. In these circumstances, the Commission asks the Chief Secretary,
Government of Odisha, to provide an interim relief of Rs. 5.00 lakhs to the next kin of the deceased, and have the entire matter enquired by CBCID.
A report on the action taken is expected within six weeks positively.
It is therefore, requested that the compliance report in the matter be sent to the Commission latest by 27/12/2013, so that the same could be placed before the Commission.

NHRC Order
NHRC Order
          Yours faithfully,
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR (LAW)